Editor's note: If you're still holding a grudge against Rose for not letting Jack onto the piece of wood that could have, in the opinion of the entire known universe, held them both, join the club! But moving on (kind of), DiCaprio is one of those rare actors who so embodies role after role that when we're watching him as Jay Gatsby he is Gatsby and nobody else. He's not Leo DiCaprio playing Gatsby or Leo DiCaprio playing Jack, he is Gatsby and Jack and every other character he plays, period. You're going to love our DiCaprio collection, guaranteed.